Should members of congress see themselves as delegates or trustees

Best answer: well, a delegate is generally free to do as he/she wants, while a trustee is suppose to act in accordance to the best interest of the beneficiary that he/she represents delegates are generally elected, while trustees are generally appointed i think that congressional reps should act more like. Max bloom section 12 a major issue that must be considered when we think about the way we want the people who we choose to represent us to behave is whether they should act as trustees or as delegates. Trustee in cases where most people have little interest in or knowledge about the issue, delegate otherwise and whenever a legislator acts more like a trustee, she should be prepared to clearly articulate why she voted the way that she did and why her constituents should agree with the decision. Delegates see themselves as the agents of those who elected them they believe that one should vote the way they think they are willing to suppress their own views, igmore th ose of their party's leaders, and turn a deaf ear to the arguments of colleagues and of special interest from outside their constituencies.

should members of congress see themselves as delegates or trustees Start studying chapter 10 congress learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools.

How does a member of congress act as a delegate delegates are willing to suppress their own views, ignore those of their party's leader's, and turn a deaf ear to the arguments of colleagues and of special interests from out side their constituencies. Trustees and delegates, or combo of the two, are not the only way members of congress vote we also must consider what role the party line vote plays many members vote the party line and use their constituent's concerns as justification for their vote. A theory of political accountability justin fox1 and kenneth w shotts2 july 23, 2007 1see stokes 2001, for an excellent discussion of the thoughts of edmund burke, james madison, bernard manin, and john stuart mill on whether citizens should evaluate candidates based on { delegate or trustee { is afiected by factors such as the.

Chapter 10 the congress section 4 the members of congress key terms trustee from history f101 at columbus alternative high school trustees - many members see themselves as holders of the public trust who must decide issues delegates - many members see themselves as agents of those who elected them and believe they should suppress their. Chapter 10 congress study play who is your us representative vickey hartzler how does a member of congress act as a trustee call all issues as they see them attempt to combine vasic elements of the trustee, delegate and partisan roles balancing conflicting factors. 15 in recent years, the political beliefs of members of congress have become what ideologically legislators who think of themselves as trustees are most likely to do what committees 22 staff members are most likely to see themselves entirely as personal advocates if they work for whom or what individual member 23 the complexity. Should members of the us congress be “delegates” or “trustees” for their constituents the framers of the constitution, to ensure that no single person or entity had a monopoly on power, instituted a system of checks and balances.

Delegates are generally elected, while trustees are generally appointed i think that congressional reps should act more like trustees, doing what is best for their beneficiaries but not acting as puppets for their beneficiaries delegates being elected are more fitting for democracy then the appointed trustee. A theory of political accountability justin fox1 and kenneth w shotts2 july 23, 2007 1see stokes 2001, for an excellent discussion of the thoughts of edmund burke, analyze retrospective voting and elected o–cials’ roles as trustees or delegates 2.

Should members of congress see themselves as delegates or trustees

Trustees call issues as they see them, regardless of the views held by their constituents or by any of the other groups that seek to influence their decisions. For me i think that us congress has probably the right of it(in structure) in that you have a senate with six year terms and a house with 2 year terms i believe that the senate should tend to act more as trustees and the house more as delegates now congress doesn't exactly always work, but this is one of the parts of the system i tend to like.

15 in recent years, the political beliefs of members of congress have become what ideologically increased reliance on staff has made congress more what individualistic 18 legislators who think of themselves as delegates are most likely to do what legislators who think of themselves as trustees are most likely to do what use own.

Likewise, we have seen many members of congress go against their constituents the first bailout is a prime example of this leads to the question, are members of congress trustees or delegates trustee means that a certain member of congress votes for what he or she thinks is best for the constituents. Trustee vs delegate be considered when we think about the way we want the people who we choose to represent us to behave is whether they should act as trustees or as delegates to find out more, including how to control cookies, see here: cookie policy. Should members of the us congress be “delegates” or “trustees” for their constituents which do you believe serves the best interests of the members of congress and of the constituents should members of congress vote according to their own views or the views of the constituents who elected them. Delegates - many members see themselves as agents of those who elected them and believe they should suppress their own views in favor of those of the electorate 4 partisans - many members see themselves as bound to vote on issues according to the party platform and the wishes of party leaders.

should members of congress see themselves as delegates or trustees Start studying chapter 10 congress learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. should members of congress see themselves as delegates or trustees Start studying chapter 10 congress learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools.
Should members of congress see themselves as delegates or trustees
Rated 5/5 based on 12 review
Download